The Schism, part 2

Jonathan: Finally, after lifetimes of research, I have managed to bring them together!
Jonathan: A diamond pimp cane: MINERAL
Jonathan: A Jack'o'lantern: VEGETABLE
Jonathan: A Fancy Chicken: ANIMAL
Jonathan: A children's story: PORNOGRAPHY
Fancy Chicken: 

Jonathan: The four fundamental elements of Life! Now, my doomsday device is nearly complete!

Jonathan: The  final ingredient I need is the last cookie.

Mike: At last!  It is my turn to regale you with my version!
Jonathan: And if Mike will just let me finish...
Jonathan: Well, I think we all know how it ends.
Dr. Cool:  
Karl:  

Dr. Cool: Hey!  Chill out, bud. You're way out of line.
Mike: *Sob*
Disembodied Voice of Narration: To be continued...
Karl:  
Jonathan: